Should I change the water or flour I feed my starter? I am using the same recipe provided by Chad Robertson's book 'Tartine Bread', only changing the water from Poland Spring to Nestle Pure Life Enriched with Minerals bottled water which is closer to a 7.0 pH.
Baking – What water should be used in baking bread
bakingbreadstarter
Related Solutions
It sounds like you may be missing a very important piece.
this
belongs here: 
At the beginning, you are throwing out a lot because you are just feeding the culture. You're just seeding the growth medium (fresh flour and water) with the young culture, so you want to be sure that the ratio of food to culture is appropriate.
Once the culture is established, you don't have to throw out any, but you do have to keep feeding it. This generally means that either you throw out a little, or have to feed it a ton. At the bakery where I work, we use so much starter that we don't throw any out. We're left with little enough at the end of the day that we just add fresh flour and water.
The ratio of starter to fresh flour and water (and ratio of flour to water) are used to control the culture. Different strains grow better at different levels of hydration, and leaving more of the already cultured starter in when you feed it can leave in more of the "waste products", like acids, which contribute to flavor.
Related Topic
- Baking – Sourdough starter issues
- Dough – Sourdough starter bubbling but not rising after months of feeding
- Bread – Making sourdough bread with just flour and water (and no starter)
- Sourdough – Why Did My Sourdough Starter Stop Growing After Day Two?
- Bread – Not feeding sourdough starter enough
- Bread – Attempting Tartine’s basic country bread
- Bread – How to avoid collapsing bread
Best Answer
Poland Spring is 7.3 and Nestle Pure Life is 7.2. It is highly unlikely that this is going to make any noticeable difference in your results. I'd say use whichever is convenient.