If a recipe calls for ten minutes hand kneading a bread dough, how long should it take to knead in a mixer using dough hooks?
Bread – Kneading bread dough
breaddough
Related Topic
- Bread – Converting kneading times from machine kneading to hand kneading
- Bread – In the new mixer, the bread dough gets wrapped around the kneading hook. How to do
- Baking – Adding too much flour to bread dough in Kitchenaid Stand Mixer
- Baking – How long should I knead bread dough by hand
- Bread – Making bread on Stand Mixer
- Baking – How to knead this dough by hand
- Bread – Kneading dough by hand
- Baking – Very Sticky Dough Before Kneading
Best Answer
It seems there is no reliable conversion formula - if you check the websites of mixer manufacturers, they go as low as 1/5 of the time (KitchenAid) or suggest machine-kneading for about 4/5 (Bosch). And I don’t think it’s just because the KitchenAid is so super fast.
The good thing is that the lack of a formula forces you to learn how to recognize a well-kneaded dough. I let you in on a little secret here: if a recipe gives a kneading time, it’s simply an estimation or approximation of how long a user may have to knead to reach a certain stage. Individual technique and even working speed varies so much, that a value like ten minutes is just ballpark number.
When you prepare a bread dough, your goal is to create a gluten structure that will trap the gasses and give you the desired crumb texture. There are two main methods:
So in short, if you really need a number (e.g. if you want to set a timer and walk away), instead of finding a generic conversion formula, you could measure how long it takes for your recipe and your machine to get a well-kneaded dough and then use that value in the future.