I did a cheesecake following this recipe (first time).
I didn’t know I had to use cream cheese at room temperature, so I took it directly from the fridge, and also I don’t have an electric mixer. So as you can imagine, it was extremely difficult to "mix cream cheese with sugar until smooth". I decided to give up on that mixing and just continue, given that with the eggs and the milk it would be much easier to mix.
In the end, I got something which looks like a cheesecake (the texture is uniform) and seems to taste like a cheesecake (not that I have much experience), but is very dense and I feel that my stomach has trouble digesting it.
Looking at the Internet, everyone says that it’s important to cream together the cream cheese and sugar very well, which I didn’t really do, so I was wondering what’s the purpose of it? Would it explain the fact that my cheesecake seems a bit too dense?
Best Answer
You are not creaming the cream cheese and sugar. "Cream" means to beat butter and sugar until you have incorporated a lot of air. "Mix cream cheese and sugar" means just that, get a homogenous mixture. There is no point (and I suspect no possibility) to actually replicate the creaming step of cakemaking with cream cheese.
Also, cheesecake filling is supposed to be dense, especially in New York style. As Deb Perelman from Smitten Kitchen says, "firm and intense is the goal". So, despite the initial difficulty, if you managed to get it smooth (which is a real challenge with cold cream cheese) it was probably as intended.