Dough – Is buttermilk preferred for sourdough starter

Normal sourdough starter is usually just flour and water. However, there are less common alternatives such as using fruit yeast and other sources of yeast.

The main problem with using things like milk or buttermilk is the danger of causing spoilage.

As another commenter already added,

"Adding milk works because milk is mostly water. It might even work better, as it also contains sugar (lactose) which will be eaten by your starter's yeasts and bacteria.

But it also contains other stuff, such as fats. And fats, after some time, get rancid. You probably won't want that taste in bread or pancakes. I would stick to water (which quite probably you'll find cheaper than milk).

Don't worry about rotten milk: your starter is already rotten. And it's a hostile environment for most microbes. It's very very improbable new microbes would survive there. But if they do, they'll be quite similar to the already existing ones."

A great overview from this comment:

"A sourdough starter is just Flour + Water + Time

Some add catalysts such as pineapple juice or grape skins etc. But what is fermenting is the flour! and this is the starter.

Once the starter is made, however you choose to make one, the finished starter will be a flour + water. The added "catalysts" are just to help make one. Once it is made then generally it is just fed flour + water to be kept going indefinitely.

There is such a thing as Yeast Water which is made and kept going with fruit but that is different.

When a starter is used in a sourdough it will be flour + water. The temperature and feeding schedule will affect the starter either making it more yeast or bacterial therefore making it more or less sour. But what also effects the final bread is how the starter is used within the dough, i.e. how much starter to use, how long the dough is fermented and at what temperature.

So many factors involved here.

No two people have exactly the same starter. And one starter can bring out different qualities in different breads depending on how it is used. And a change in feeding can change your starter.

Welcome to sourdough."

Best practices from Colorado State University:

"Considerations for bread starter variations: Amish Friendship Bread: Although rare, there have been incidents of foodborne illness associated with friendship-style bread, which differs from traditional sourdough by addition of milk and sugar, and thus provides an environment which could support growth of harmful microorganisms. To limit introductions of harmful bacteria in friendship bread starter, use pasteurized milk or cultured (soured) dairy and ferment in a refrigerator, not at room temperature."

Signs your starter may have gone wrong:

"Signs of Contamination A starter should be white, light gray or light tan. It should smell like bread dough, of yeast or of its ingredients. It should bubble subtly and occasionally burp. If the starter has liquid on top of it -- this is called hooch, and it is the alcohol the starter’s yeast produces from fermentation -- it should be clear, white, light gray or light brown. If the starter or its hooch is pink, green or dark brown, discard the starter. If it smells or looks moldy, discard the starter. If the starter is fizzing or the starter has spots or patches -- which are signs of foreign bacterial growth -- discard the starter."