I tried to cook a butternut squash curry, and I feel that the squash wasn't exactly "infused" with the sauce. I've had similar experiences with making gratin, and I feel I may be making the same mistake.
As for the recipe, it is basically:
- heat up butter, cook garlic and ginger.
- throw in curry powder, after a minute add in the squash + cream.
- bring the mixture to a boil, then cover and lower the heat.
- cook around 20 min, then uncover and raise the heat for 5 min.
The result was very tasty, so it wasn't a failure, but I felt like the dish came in two parts: the sauce, and the squash. They didn't really 'join forces' so to speak, which is something that I feel is a hallmark for a good curry (squash, pumpkin, etc). To try and be more explicit I expected the squash chunks to be more creamy and moist. Mine seemed to resemble a baked potato in terms of texture, a little dry and grainy. The flavors also seemed to remain separate (most of the flavor being in the sauce), whereas I was expecting the sauce/flavor to be absorbed by the squash.
Side note: the recipe asked for coconut milk, and I used whipping cream and water as a substitute, hope that wasn't the culprit…
Best Answer
I think you expected to get curry flavored squash chunks, but it doesn't work like that. Sliced up squash simply isn't going to absorb that much flavor. If you really want to meld the two you need to physically combine the two. You could either smash it all up, or use a blender of some kind, of the two mashing would be my choice as it would preserve some texture.
If preserving the chunked-up texture of the squash is important to you then try blending 1/4 of your cooked squash with all of the sauce, then reducing it down a bit in a pan before adding the squash back in, that will make the sauce much more squash-y.
Also, I'd recommend you use coconut milk next time, it has much more flavor than whipping cream and water, and flavor is what you need.