I have a recipe for Rum Balls that calls for "Fine Oats." I couldn't find anything at bulk barn so I ended up with "Scotch Oats" after talking to a rep. I've never eaten oats before so I'm not sure if I can eat these particular oats raw and if I should blend it to make it more powder-like (if that's what fine oats are).
Oats Substitution – Scotch Oats to Substitute Fine Oats in Rum Balls
oatsrawsubstitutions
Related Topic
- Baking Substitutions – Can Rolled Oats Be Replaced with Instant Oats in Cookies?
- Rum Balls Recipe – Replacing Vanilla Wafers in Rum Balls
- Oats – Dealing with Dust and Stems in Packaged Oats
- Recipe calls for rolled oats, I have old fashioned oats – can I substitute them in cookies
- Oats – Can I Heat Up Overnight Oats? The Best Methods Explained
- Should I buy more expensive oats
- Quantity for over night oats
- Raw Oats – Is There Such a Thing as Unsteamed Rolled Oats?
Best Answer
You should be able to figure out pretty easily if you can eat your Scotch oats raw - just put some in your mouth. Is it hard as a rock, or soft enough to comfortably chew?
Anyway, Scotch oats, which may or may not be the same thing as Scottish oats (depending on the producer) are typically fairly roughly milled uncooked oat groats. If you got yours from Bulk Barn, it may look like this:
I had not heard of fine oats before - probably because they're typically marketed more as a nutritional supplement than a cooking ingredient.
According to The Protein Works,
Two things in that description make me think that Scotch oats won't be a perfect substitute. First, Scotch oats could probably not be added to a protein shake without being cooked first. Second, I don't believe oats are typically considered to have a low Glycemic Index value. The Mayo clinic lists them as a "Medium GI" food: Glycemic index diet: What's behind the claims
I don't know if something is done to fine oats to change their nutritional properties, or if this is just a disagreement about Glycemic Index labeling.
If you're not concerned about the Glycemic Index value of your rum balls (and it seems hard to imagine low GI rum balls), this doesn't matter. The only important thing is whether the texture of the Scotch oats be suitable. My sense is that they will be too firm to chew without cooking. Some rum ball recipes call for brief cooking, which may be enough to soften the Scotch oats. But if yours is a recipe that involves no cooking, and if you have the means, you may want to grind those oats more finely.