I successfully obtained a working sourdough starter using rye and wheat flour, water, and grated apple. The dough made with it rose in a banetton and was inverted onto a hot baking stone. The bread had a good crumb, was thoroughly baked and moist. That to say that the starter worked.
I am puzzled by the starter's aroma. It is not the smell of a starter going bad, more like a slightly bitter undertone, like beer. The starter is fed regularly and is still bubbling away, but the undertone is persisting. It has not affected the quality or flavor of the bread. Any ideas?
Starter with water, flour, grated apple
starter
Related Topic
- Bread – What type of flour should I feed the starter with
- Baking – Amish Friendship Bread starter with buttermilk
- Bread – Maintaining Sourdough Starter – Are potato flakes/water necessary
- Dough – Sourdough starter began acting strange after storing in fridge
- Dough – How to properly substitute flour and water for sourdough starter
- Dough – Sourdough starter bubbling but not rising after months of feeding
- Dough – My sourdough starter stopped growing after day two
- Bread – Can’t seem to get the rye sourdough starter really going
Best Answer
How old is it? If it's newer than a few months, it could easily just be that you still have a huge variety of bacteria vying for dominance, and some slightly foul ones still remain, and haven't been kicked out yet. If it still tastes good and doesn't smell like acetone it should be fine.