I've heard that you can revitalized lumpty or hard brown sugar, but also that doing so doesn't recover the actual flavor. Does baking with other brown sugar that is "revitalized" really impact cookie flavor? What about white granulatd sugar?
Sugar – I’ve heard that sugar, and especially brown sugar, loses its flavor over time. Is this true
brown-sugarsugar
Related Topic
- Baking – Do I need hard or soft brown sugar for brownies
- Sugar – the best sugar for sweet short crust pastry
- Baking – Why does some cookie recipes both put sugar and brown sugar? Also can we use sweetener like stevia instead of sugar in recipes
- Sugar – Difference between brown sugar and white sugar
- Bread – What type of baker percentage should one use for brown sugar when compared to white sugar
- Flavor – Blackstrap molasses vs regular molasses
Best Answer
White sugar is generally sucrose and has been heavily refined, so it won't undergo any chemical changes over time. In fact, sugar is actually used as a preservative.
Brown sugar is a bit different. It gets hard simply because it loses moisture - i.e. the water evaporates - and that won't cause the taste to change. However, some people have reported brown sugar actually fermenting on its own (also here). This fermentation is more likely to happen than in white sugar due to the presence of molasses.
It takes a long time for fermentation to occur, but it can definitely occur, and that will most certainly change the flavour. I'm not sure if I'd call it "losing" the flavour; some might argue that the presence of alcohol is a good thing, although fermented sugar obviously will not be as sweet.
I would not worry about the flavour of brown sugar that has merely hardened; if it smells like alcohol, though, you might want to be more careful.