Thanksgiving and Christmas of last year I tried my hand at frying a turkey.
Everything was fine but I could never seem to get the peanut oil up to 350℉ (175℃).
I followed Alton Brown's Recipe but just couldn't reach 350℉. The best i did was 275℉ to 300℉ (135℃ to 150℃) which meant I left the turkey in a little longer and burned it a little too much.
Any advice?
Best Answer
If you are saying you cannot get the oil hot enough during pre-heating:
If you are using a purpose-built commercial turkey fryer, I suggest consulting the book or contacting the company. If you built the rig yourself, I suggest more fire! (and lots of safety precautions)
Now... if you are talking about a temperature drop after you dunk the bird, realize that is totally normal.
Alton Brown suggests a preheat temperature of 250 degrees. He suggests raising the temp to 350 after the bird is in the bath but adds the following advice:
You may need to use a smaller turkey to achieve the internal temperature you want without burning the outside. I'd look for something in the ballpark of 10 pounds. If you are cooking for a crowd, it's best to go with multiple birds instead of going bigger.
Be mindful of carry-over cooking: