Crab – Why Phillips Crab Tastes Like Chemicals Compared to M&S’s Orkney Crab

crab

BC supermarkets stock only Phillips Food for picked crab meat. Thrifty Foods sell them in plastic cylinders:

enter image description here

  1. To me, Phillips's crab always tastes wacky, like chemicals. Does anyone taste this or know why?

  2. In England, I stumbled on White and White & Brown Orkney Crab at M&S Foodhall. It tasted truly crabby, delicious and fresh, unlike Phillips. Why?

enter image description here

Best Answer

A quick comparison of the listed ingredients shows only crab meat for the M&S products (clearly visible in the photos in your question), whereas the Phillip’s website of the pictured product says:

Ingredients: Crab Meat, Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate (SAPP) added to prevent the formation of struvite crystals.

Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate is also called Disodium pyrophosphate and the Wikipedia article states:

Disodium pyrophosphate can leave a slightly bitter aftertaste in some products,

In short, you taste something because there is something other than just crab meat. If SAPP tastes unpleasant to you, avoid products with it and choose ones without a preservative or with a different one (if a taste test is ok for you). In a pinch, masking the off taste may be possible, but not necessarily what you are looking for - you’d also be masking the crab flavor.