Are magnetic bit holders interchangable

tools

Originally I bought a Dewalt bit set and they have their own magnetic sleeve that goes over bits to magnetize them. It works well but because it's a sleeve if the bit is in an extension the sleeve cannot be used as there is not enough space to slide down.

Next I bought a makita holder which is like a little extension but claims to magnetize bits.

Finally I bought a new set of bits by Milwaukee on discount which includes a similar little extension that claims to magnetize bits.

Milwaukee extension + Milwaukee bits = pleasure to use works great.
Makita extension + Milwaukee or Dewalt bits = does literally NOTHING.
Milwaukee extension + Dewalt bits = works ok not great.

So what I don't get is are there different types of magnets and alloys that each company uses?

Is Makita intended to work with Makita bits?

Why does combining Milwaukee/Dewalt produces worse hold.

Best Answer

I have bits from Bosch, Makita and DeWalt but also many cheap ones.

They all fit into various holders from the above names as well as some no-name ones.

The magnetic hold is different on all holders - some are strong and will hold suitable screws while others “just” manage to hold the bit.