Ceiling – Will this ceiling fan box replacement work in old work hole

ceiling-fanjunction-box

I have had a hanging light fixture in the middle of the living room which I now want to replace with a ceiling fan+light. Nothing huge and fancy… but a hunter nonetheless.

The old pan box was, old (complete with knob & tube which I will not be re-using):

old pancake box

It was stuck in this hole in the ceiling (screwed to an old oak board that is jambed tight between joists):

hole in ceiling

So my question is… will this box work:

enter image description here

Is it valid? If I bolt it to the old oak board using 4 hex screws (probably number 10s)?

With the oak board in the ceiling how it is, I don't really have room to use one of those hefty giant metal-bar contraptions.

Best Answer

Pictured is a random one dollar 4" octagon box.

That is acceptable for a lamp, but won't do at all for a ceiling fan box.

Since you're rewiring anyway, you'd be better off to spend a latté worth of cost to put a ceiling fan box here and use /3 cable from the switch. That way the next occupant has a choice about putting a ceiling fan here. Obviously the last occupant thought it was worthwhile.