Electrical – adapter dual switch

electrical

The switch in this adaptor only disconnects one of the live lines. What kind of switch where both are disconnected when you turn it off?

enter image description here

What is the advantage of the latter (or hazard of the former)?

top and bottom view of it. It's 240 volts. 2 live hots.

enter image description here

enter image description here

Best Answer

Philippines:

You're sunk. You can't do that with this adapter. It's not a Philippines adapter, it's a North America/Japan adapter.

(For our readers, the former USA-developed areas of the Philippines use USA-style split-phase, but for nationalism reasons serve only 240V so neutral does not exist. This makes it compatible with the rest of the country which uses standard Euro 1-of-3-phases of 230V. In USA areas, since both wires are far from ground potential, both must be switched for safety.)

This problem is greatly compounded by the unfortunate policy in the Philippines of using the NEMA 1 and NEMA 5 receptacles for 240V (when there's a perfectly good spec called NEMA 6 specifically for what they are doing, but good luck telling a whole country they're using the wrong socket). So you have polarized NEMA 5 receptacles with the neutral being 120V from earth and the hot being the opposite 120V from earth.

Honestly, you will never find a BS1363 that switches both legs. That is simply not required for that appication (anywhere else but Philippines). I would advise actually installing a proper BS1363 right next to a 2-pole switch, and then superglue and sticker over the on-socket switch, so people use the off-socket switch.

Although honestly, Britain are the only people in the world who put switches on receptacles.

Everywhere else in North America, Colombia and Japan:

Under the UK BS1363 standard, the switch on the socket is required to switch off the hot wire. The neutral wire is (supposed to be) near earth potential, so there's not a lot of hazard to leaving it connected. So there is no need to switch neutral.

Hence one which switches both is unlikely to exist.

North America's voltage is lower, but has the same "hot + neutral + earth" scheme, with neutral also (supposed to be) near earth potential.

It needs to be polarized so the switch is switching the 120V hot wire. On the NEMA 1 and NEMA 5 15A connectors, polarization is done one of two ways:

  • The ground pin assures correct orientation of the socket.
  • The neutral slot on a socket is taller than the hot slot, so 2-prong plugs simply have a taller neutral pin.

On 3-prong plugs, they don't bother with the tall neutral.

This thing appears to be 2-prong and with no polarization. It's an incompetently designed Cheese cheapie, and the switch is theater (because 50% of the time it'll be switching the neutral). No testing lab stamp, of course.