Electrical – Shop Electrical – MWBC Serving 240V and 120V Outlets

electricalgaragemwbcworkshop

I've seen this setup in use in other shops and am interested in using the technique myself. However, the mere mention of it seems to incite rabid pandemonium rather than civil discourse.

Drawing

I'd very much like to learn more about any potential safety concerns, especially if its use violates the national electrical code. I've been researching this for some time and have thus far found no issues with its use despite stern warnings and admonition from folks that were unable to articulate the reasons they felt it was a bad idea or cite the NEC code that prohibits the configuration.

If there are indeed issues with its use as many suggest, I would like to understand the reasoning behind those issues.

This is for a 1-man garage workshop where GFCI is required for 120V receptacles. I'd like to put several of these in. Each electrical box will have a dedicated home run back to a 100A subpanel. The 240V outlets will be used for tools with 240V single phase motors like a 3HP table saw, 3HP jointer, 2HP band saw, and 2HP dust collector. 120V outlets will be used for smaller tools like handheld drills, sanders, routers, etc.

Each electrical box:

  • One (1) 240V 20A double pole breaker
  • 12/3 Romex; red (hot), black (hot), white (neutral), bare copper (ground)
  • One (1) two-gang PVC electrical box
  • One (1) commercial spec 6-20R receptacle
  • One (1) commercial spec 5-20R GFCI receptacle

There are commercial dual-voltage outlets available (without GFCI protection), so it would seem this notion is not as outlandish, unacceptable, or dangerous as some would suggest. Here are a couple examples:

  • Leviton 5842-I (20A)
  • Eaton/Cooper 829V (15A)

This article seems to indicate this configuration is acceptable and safe as long as all rules and exceptions are accounted for. As far as I can tell, my drawing above complies with those rules and exceptions.

Is this truly acceptable? Complies with NEC? Will pass inspection? It seems pretty clear to me there is no issue. Perhaps I'm still missing something, hence the question.

Additional reference: NEC 210.4 Multiwire Branch Circuits (MWBC)

Thanks!

Best Answer

Yeah, I work a lot with MWBC. That looks fine to me... It should limbo under the NEC 2017 guidelines. If you don't get this permitted by the time your state adopts NEC 2020, then your entire plan falls apart. At that point you'll need a 2-pole GFCI breaker, and the GFCI recep will be superfluous.

Your best defense to NEC 2020 is to get a HUGE panel. That way if the inspector nails you on a bunch of 2-pole GFCI requirements, you can just pop em in. For that reason I recommend you plan never to use double-stuff breakers; you can't upgrade them to AFCI/GFCI. Huge panels (like more than twice what you ever envision using) are cheap insurance. We generally try to help people save money, but chintzing out on panels is false economy.

The only exception is more of a suspicion. You generally have 240V loads when the load is too large for 120V. So that suggests a 240V appliance that will be 8A or more. If you try to use that at the same time as a high draw 120V appliance, you could overload that leg. For instance if you have a 11A 240V load and a 12A 120V load, the current on your 3 wires will be 11A - 12A - 23A. Which ain't gonna fly on a 20A breaker.