How to convince plumber that there is a gas leak

gasgasleakleaknatural-gas

I had some gas lines replaced in the crawl space and the next day after the plumber left I noticed a minor gas smell. I got into crawl space with a HomeFlex leak detector and it is clearly going off full blast around one connection. However, I couldn't see any bubbles with liquid leak detector.

I called the plumber back and he also couldn't see a leak with soapy water.
I am fairly certain that there is a leak because I smell it and repeated tests with the HomeFlex detector clearly show the area has gas present. It's a bit of a confined space but not completely blocked.

Why would soapy water not show anything?

Is there any additional way to test for leaks? Pressure test?


Resolution

I was able to get some bubbles as a proof of leak. Then plumber tightened the connection and said it's fixed. It was not and my HomeFlex meter was still going off like crazy but I couldn't get anymore bubbles. At this point plumber had more trust in the meter, took apart the joint and discovered badly cut edge on TracPipe and fixed it.
After that I demanded full pressure test at the meter which he performed to my satisfaction and there are no more leaks and my meter stays quiet on every joint!
I definitely think that this inexpensive meter does a good job.

Best Answer

The other answers here are good from a technical point of view about how to verify a leak, but to answer the question of "how to convince a plumber", I'll second a comment by @manassehkatz: call the gas company.

Any time I've suspected a leak the gas/energy provider has been very quick to send someone out with their own tester (not just a soapy water check). They are quite literally professionals at detecting gas leaks.

If they find evidence of a gas leak, that should be reason enough for the plumber to re-check and redo the work.