Is a PTHP an HVAC option for a super or well insulated structure

ductlessheat-pumphvacinsulation

Is a Packaged Terminal Heat Pump a good HVAC system for a structure that is super insulated or passively insulated assuming the unit is sized and fitted to meet the needs of the structure.

There is not really much mentioned about PTHP and very well insulated buildings. Every publication out there dealing with well insulated structures seems to be all mini split ductless or small duct high velocity hvac systems. Are PTHPs worth considering in place of the other just mentioned options? Below is a potential list of advantages and disadvantages that I came up with for considering a PTHP system, it seems to have some pretty good advantages. Why are we not seeing more of these in well insulated building projects, am I missing something, sans the larger whole in the wall I would think these units would work well where a mini split wall unit would go?

a PTAC

Advantages

  1. more reasonable pricing than ductless split systems

  2. Usually offer inlet fresh air vent, that could be worked into a low cost fresh air vent with a exhaust vent wired into the fan thermostat circuit.

  3. Ususally offer standard 24VAC thermostat control, perfect for smart home integration.

  4. Reasonably efficient depending on which models selected with a range of 10-13 EER.

  5. Usually has back up electrical resistance heat as a 2nd stage heat option for colder climates

  6. Available in under 1 TON sizes as small as 7000 BTUs

Disadvantages

  1. Potential an issue since it will require a large about 43" x 16" hole to be placed in the wall, not sure if this would be a massive air / thermal transfer leak surface area even if a air tight seal is accomplished around the unit

  2. Usually do not have a dedicated de-humidification / dry mode like many mini ductless systems do

  3. Is not a efficient as mini ductless systems

Best Answer

The point of a super insulated home or a Passive house is that they rely on the body heat of the occupants plus the heat from the various gadgets in the home to keep them warm, with the insulation slowing the heat loss. A home built to Passive house standard will usually be fitted with hydronic heating (probably as the new owners are not sure that it will do what it says on the tin.) And the heating may never be used. Of the 37, 000 Passive houses in the world, 20, 000 or so are in Germany where 92% of the owners are satisfied with their economy. A true Passive house is almost air tight, with a heat recovery ventilation system, fitted with a in duct heating coil to warm the incoming cold winter air, should it be 3.5C or more lower than the room temperature. You can see from the above that having a large hole in a wall, albeit sealed with a steel sheet, where a vast amount of heat can escape will defeat the whole point of carefully installed insulation.