Plumbing – Is it ok for a bathroom sink vent to go up and come back down over an obstacle

code-compliancedrain-waste-ventplumbing

I think this question has been asked before but I can't quite find exactly my situation.

I'm pretty sure this isn't to code, either, except the IPC code section 905.2 apparently says

All vent and branch vent pipes shall be so graded and connected as to
drain back to the drainage pipe by gravity.

which this arrangement arguably does have.

I have a bathroom in an old (1928) home. I am gutting it and I want to reuse the existing stack vent. But I'm replacing all other plumbing, including the main part of the stack. I was going to cut the old stack at the bottom of the vent and guide the new stack into the old vent.

Old stack is 4" cast iron. So is the old stack vent.

The new shower drain and toilet will use the stack vent directly.

However, to make use of the old vent for the sink, which is going to be on the opposite wall to the old vent stack, I'd have to route the vent pipe up and over the steep roof gable, and back down.

I think the answer is going to be "create a new vent for the sink and poke it through the roof" — and I'm ok with that. But I did just get this roof replaced 3 years ago and I'd hate to poke a hole in it if I didn't have to.

Images for clarity

Old vent stack — black cast iron going up and to the left.

enter image description here

Proposed vent including question area (in dashed red oval)

enter image description here

Detail showing the steepness of the roof angle

enter image description here

Best Answer

All vent and branch vent pipes shall be so graded and connected as to drain back to the drainage pipe by gravity.

which this arrangement arguably does have.

I believe that as the code is typically interpreted, the latter half is draining "forward" (in the direction of the vent) rather than "back" even though the water (condensation, mostly) ends up in the same drain pipe ultimately.

Practically speaking I can't see that it should not work, and IPC tends to have so many ways to vent things I would not swear it's not allowed in some paragraph I missed (or found not relevant to my situation) when educating myself for my own plumbing, but I don't think it quite passes.