Should I replace this 4“ furnace filter with a 5” one
hvac
I got a new furnace this year, and want to replace the filter. It's 4" (actually 3 5/8), but the cabinet looks like it would easily take 5.
Would a 5" replacement be better? Or should I just get another 4"?
Best Answer
The whole point of a nice filter cabinet like that is to have a tight fit so very little air bypasses the filter otherwise you might as well just stick a cheap filter in there. Those usually take a manufacturer specific filter to fit properly. Most universal filters are under sized so they can fit most cabinets, just bit well. Manufacturer specific filters are usually more money but should fit like a glove.
I have the same filter location as referenced by Steve Armstrong. There is no slot for the filter but it is just held in place over the return duct by a metal arm.
It's common for HVAC systems to be improperly designed. It's also a common misconception that it's okay to close vents. If a regular density filter is restricting airflow (and causing the unit to heat up too much and trip a safety switch) then you need to do something about the airflow.
In general it's not a good idea to close vents because it changes the "static pressure". I don't know the details but basically you don't want the pressure in your vents to be much higher than the pressure in your house. If so the fan is working too hard and there isn't enough air passing over the heat exchanger.
Best Answer
The whole point of a nice filter cabinet like that is to have a tight fit so very little air bypasses the filter otherwise you might as well just stick a cheap filter in there. Those usually take a manufacturer specific filter to fit properly. Most universal filters are under sized so they can fit most cabinets, just bit well. Manufacturer specific filters are usually more money but should fit like a glove.