Shower – cracked shower tile/underlayment

bathroomshowertile

I had three cracked floor tiles in the shower and just removed them thinking I'd just simply replace and grout. However, after removing I noticed a lot of moisture and as you can see from the picture, there is a crack underneath exactly where the tiles were cracked. The shower hasn't been used for two days and if I dry this area it becomes saturated again within minutes, with water seeping up through this crack. Do I need to keep going down further? I don't believe the liner is torn as I have no leaks below. The home is 7 yrs old.

enter image description here

Best Answer

If the liner is good you don't need to go down more, though if you replace with the same size tile it may crack in the same place if there's a (evidently) structural issue there.

I'd be inclined to fill the hole with an "accent stripe" of 1" tile so the crack (when it re-cracks, as seems likely) can follow a grout line rather than crack the face of a tile.