What are normally-open hydronic zone valves used for

hydronicvalvezoned-heating

In a hydronic (hot water) heating system electronically operated valves control whether hot water runs through a particular zone of the building, or not.

It seems to be a common setup for the valve to 'default' to being CLOSED to flow, and only open when commanded to do so via a thermostat signal. This seems logical (to me), as you only want heat supplied when you actually need it. This is the "normally closed" type.

However, manufacturers also sell a "normally open" type which would be OPEN to flow all the time, unless some control signal says otherwise.

What application(s) requires the normally open variant?


Note — Ditto for a chilled water system used for cooling, AFAIK.

Best Answer

Choice of normally open or normally closed for a valve actuator is part of the overall controls design process, part of which is considering safety/protective functions.

As an example, consider a climate where it gets freezing cold (below 0 degrees C). You have a normally closed heating valve that is closed. Something happens such that your electronic valve actuator no longer receives power (board burns out, breaker trips, etc). Now imagine you are away from home for an extended period of time, and you don't know your valve is now stuck closed, and it gets freezing cold. The zone will have no heating, and the consequences of no heating to the zone could be a burst pipe and a flooded home. Had the valve been normally open, you would likely be wasting energy overheating the space, but no burst pipe.

Note that normally open/normally closed is often used to mean fail open/fail closed, but they are not necessarily the same thing. Motor actuators without specific additional features (spring return, capacitor driven return, etc, backup power) do not have a fail safe state on loss of power, they fail in place. Normally open/normally closed can describe the valve state at the control signal input of zero/false/off.

By the way, there are other valve actuators used in hydronic heating systems besides electronically operated actuators. Pneumatic actuators and mechanical (thermostatic) actuators also exist.