Wood – Open Riser Stairs / Removing carpeting and converting to hardwood

carpethardwood-refinishingstairs

We have a staircase from the first floor to the second floor. The stairs are open riser, with the treads wrapped in carpet. The reach a landing and then transition to closed risers.

View of open riser stairs

Some treads are a bit loose. So, we're already working to remove and repair a single tread.

Replacing the tread after the screw heads sheared off

Image of stair tread with worn carpet

I noticed the treads appear to be solid wood. Is this an opportunity to replace the treads with solid hardwood or use plywood with a hardwood veneer + bullnose around the existing treads?

Is the process for refurbishing open stairs similar to closed risers:

  1. Remove carpet
  2. Cover treads with thin hardwood or plywood with hardwood veneer
  3. Add bullnose to the front of the tread

A few basic questions:

  • Is this a conventional project? I don't see many examples on the web. This suggest that it is not common. Why? Are there important reasons not to replace the carpet on open riser stairs with wood?
  • What is the conventional method of covering the underside of the tread (see image below)? The portion of the tread that faces away from those that are traveling up/down the stairs (e.g. the underside of the tread)?
  • Is adding 1/2 inch to the top of the tread going to make the first step noticeably rise too high? Will it make the last step before the landing rise too little?

Image from underneath the stairs, looking up

Best Answer

I'll try to address your questions, though they're still a bit nebulous.

Is this an opportunity to replace the treads with solid hardwood?
Sure. Why not? As far as I'm concerned, a weekend presents such an opportunity.

Is this a conventional project?
No. Why does that matter?

The reason may be that there aren't many open-riser stairs to begin with, and it's not often that stair treads get replaced in general. That doesn't mean you can't or shouldn't.

What is the conventional method of covering the underside of the tread?
I'm not quite sure what this means. If you're installing wood treads they'll be wood on the bottom, too. If you're wondering about the steel brackets, I'd paint them or have them powder-coated, maybe. Stainless might be another option if you want high-class. You'd have to have a machine shop cut sections from angle stock and drill for bolts. I might invert them for an exposed style and so you can fit the treads well to the stringer/skirt. Speaking of, obviously you'll need to strip and refinish that.

Is adding 1/2 inch to the top of the tread going to make the first step noticeably rise too high?
Well, it would, but you're reworking your mounts anyway, so you can set them to the proper height.

A few other thoughts...

Tread options that come to mind:

  • Solid oak (not really that expensive if you buy them from a big box store)
  • Bullnosed construction-grade pine/fir lumber (2x10 or 12)--I've built such a set in my own home and it was beautiful

Some general notes:

  • Wooden treads can be slippery; consider placing silica grit in the upper varnish or wrapping them with a thin runner
  • Open-riser stairs are actually illegal in many cases nowdays for safety reasons--more than a few broken legs have resulted from slips through the void
  • Recognize that you have fewer stringers than modern stairs; be aware of how much strength and stiffness you'll need in a tread for safety and a quality feel
Related Topic