Grammar – ‘Doing Something the Traditional Way’ or ‘In the Traditional Way’?

expressionsgrammaridiomatic-languagemeaningprepositions

John is learning English the traditional way.

John is learning English in the traditional way.

I would expect an "in" before a particular way: "doing something in the traditional way."

So, are both of these usages correct:
"doing something in a particular way" or "doing something the particular way" (without in)

Regards,

Best Answer

Neither is incorrect, although it sounds far more idiomatic without "in", and that isn't a personal preference.

"Way", in this context, is often used interchangeably with 'style' or 'manner', both of which do require "in", for example:

  • It was done in the style of...
  • ...the manner in which it was done...

However, "way" literally means a route, or a direction, not strictly a style, and is more synonymous with 'method'.

Saying "in this way" can change the meaning - for example, if we said "walk this way", it would idiomatically mean in this direction; however, if we said "walk in this way", it would mean in this style, or manner.