Phrase Meaning – How Did You Make It This Far vs How Have You Made It This Far

phrase-choicephrase-meaningphrase-usage

Example:

You said you couldn't run. How did you make it this far then?

You said you couldn't run. How have you made it this far then?

Is there any difference between the two? Or they mean the same thing?

Best Answer

Their meaning is near identical. There is a slight shade of emphasis because of the verb tense, though. "How did you make it this far" puts the emphasis on what might have happened to get you here—it asks you to explain your past. "How have you made it this far" puts the emphasis on your current situation—it asks you to explain your present.