Phrases – Is the Negation ‘If Not That, Then Something’ Correct?

phrases

As in the question, if I answer someone for example "if not that coat, then I'd not recognize you" is that correct? I understand that there are other forms like "if it wasn't for that coat…", just wondering about this one specific form.

Best Answer

I answer someone for example "if not that coat, then I'd not recognize you" is that correct?

No, it isn't.

The construction is

"If it were not for that coat, [then] I would not recognize you."

or, in the past tense:

"If it had not been for that coat, [then] I would not have recognized you." (Older version = "Had it not been for that coat, [then] I would not have recognized you.")

Both if clauses are in the subjunctive because he is in the coat and you did recognise him.

You cannot omit the bolded words. Words are omitted when there is a reasonable expectation of the listener being able to supply them.

It is possible to use "if not X then Y," but X and Y must be noun phrases:

A: "Take a coat. If not the green one, then the other." Note how the same omitted verb is provided (take) and is then omitted in the if clause.