Prepositions – Correct Use of ‘Are Of’ vs. ‘Is Of’

parts-of-speechprepositional-phrasesprepositions

While I was reading a book, the following sentence caught my eye.

Sincerity and courtesy are of desirable character traits.

I saw this kind of sentence before, but never fully understood why the preposition 'of' is used. If I remove the preposition 'of', the sentence become..

Sincerity and courtesy are desirable character traits.

To me, both sentences convey the same meaning. I have also seen sentences like..

The man is of great importance.

So do we really need a preposition in these scenarios? If yes, then why and how to use the preposition 'of' properly with 'is/are'?

Best Answer

The first example is ungrammatical. The second example is correct.
The third example is grammatical, but it is not comparable to the second.

The second example "sincerity and courtesy are ... traits", equates the predicate to the subject.

The third example doesn't equate the predicate to the subject, but says that the subject has a particular property.
This corresponds to a particular meaning of "of":
M-W "of" 10
"—used as a function word to indicate a characteristic or distinctive quality or possession, for example, a woman of courage."

Related Topic