Learn English – “Ball” and “bowl” do they really sound the same

phoneticspronunciation

To my non-native ears, they always do even though the dictionary says otherwise. Do you say the two words in the same way in your speech?

Additional information that might be useful:

I understand and recognize the difference between the two. It's just the difference seems to vanish in fast-paced native speech. I'm asking about whether native speakers ignore the somewhat subtle difference in their casual fast-paced conversations, and produce the two words/sounds in the same way. I wanted to confirm whether that was true or I was just hearing things.

My native language is Arabic. I can tell whether the speaker's accent is American, British, Canadian, etc., but honestly, both Brits and Americans gave me the same experience. I can determine from context which word is meant. Because my ears are not well-trained to hear a British accent, the difference is almost impossible for me to grasp in British casual fast-paced speech.

Best Answer

English has a lot more vowels than most languages, so most learners need to re-train their ears to recognize the additional vowels. In both British English and American English, the difference between ball and bowl is small, but significant. It is easy for native speakers to recognize because their ears are trained to do so.

In ball, the vowel is a long vowel: that means that it sounds the same all the way through. The same long vowel occurs in law- /lɔː/ in BrE and /lɑː/ in AmE.

In bowl, the vowel is a diphthong, which means that there is a glide between two different sounds. The same diphthong occurs in low- /ləʊ/ in BrE and /loʊ/ in AmE.

You can see the difference clearly in this spectrogram of a British English speaker saying ball and bowl. In the first word, ball, the long vowel is the same all the way through. In the second word, bowl, the diphthong sound changes, starting at the red cursor line.

Ball bowl spectrogram

Regarding your comment about casual, fast-paced conversations: when people speak casually, and when they speak quickly, the parts that lose clarity are the function words: the little words that provide the structure for the language.

Take the word and, for example: the strong form is /ænd/, but most of the time we use the weak form /ənd/. As speech gets progressively faster and/or more casual, it becomes /ən/ and finally /n/.

Meanwhile, the important words- nouns like ball and bowl- are usually stressed, and don't soften up in the same way. The central vowel in a stressed word is about as protected as you can get.

You might get some de-stressing if the noun is preceded by an adjective (the red ball) or when it's part of a compound noun (a furball), and this might weaken the clarity a little, but not, in my opinion, enough to make it impossible to discriminate for a native listener with the same accent.

Related Topic