Learn English – Correctness of “on this view”

prepositionsword-choice

When referencing a perspective, I have always thought that "in this view, …". However, I have discovered that "on this view, …" is very common. I find this very odd! It sounds plain wrong to me (English is my second language).

Can someone explain why this is correct? Are both correct? Is only "on this view" correct?

Some context: It seems "on this view" is used often in philosophy.
"Take, for example, the proposition that you will have lunch tomorrow. On this view, that proposition either has no truth value right now, or else has the value indeterminate." [Source]
Why not use "in this view" here?

This discussion on Reddit doesn't give a conclusive answer.

Best Answer

View can have the meaning of "way/method/basis of understanding something." When you accept such a view, it will affect what you consider true/false and how you perceive things.

When you are in a view, you are part of and affected by the view. The view will affect what you consider true/false/real/unreal, etc.

On is the a preposition used to communicate the topic of an item, so on a view communicates more that you are talking about the view or considering the view as a topic, but not necessarily using that view to determine what is true/false/real/unreal, etc.


Example:

I don't have an opinion on his view.

You don't have an opinion about the way he understands something.

I don't have an opinion in his view.

He believes you don't have an opinion - since he is "in" his view.

Related Topic