What is the difference between the following sentences?
He has failed the exam for the first time.
He has failed the exam the first time around.
Do those phrases have indentical meanings? If they do, than what is the point of using the word around in the second sentence?
Best Answer
No, they do not mean the same thing. Not only does around make the second sentence grammatical, but the use of for in the first sentence gives that sentence a different meaning.
He may have written the exam five times before. But this time, the sixth time, he has failed it. It is the first time that he has failed it.
This means that it's the first time he's written the exam—and that he's failed it.
The sentence construction is a bit odd, but it works if you think of somebody announcing the result immediately after the attempt—and just before he attempts it a second time.
Note the difference that around makes in variations of the sentence:
In the has failed version, the sentence becomes ungrammatical if you simply remove around. However, I can't really explain why this is the case.
The final version without around seems correct, but it is also awkward; I would add he wrote it to the end.