Meaning and Usage – Differences Between ‘Earlier in July’ and ‘In Early July’

meaningusage

My Question:

(1) Andy quit his job earlier in July.

(2) Andy quit his job in early July.

What are the differences between (1) and (2)?


My guess:

(1) implies that the speaker can be at any time point (like in August, in December, or even in the next year) after Andy's quitting the job.

(2) implies that the speaker is still in the same month when Andy quit his job.

Best Answer

(1) Andy quit his job earlier in July. - Using 'earlier' requires a comparison. So it is saying he quit at some point in July before a different point in July. This other point would be mentioned either in the same sentence or in a previous one.

(2) Andy quit his job in early July. - "Early July" is a phrase that means 'in the early part of July'. It roughly means the first half or third of the month but this is not fixed. It may vary depending on the speaker's opinions. This sentence is simply saying that in quit in the earlier part of July. It would be unlikely that you would say this in July (instead using something like "Early this month") so it probably said at some point after July but this is not guaranteed.