Pronouns – Does ‘The Man Saw the Woman Who is Bringing the Telescope’ Mean the Woman?

attachment-ambiguitypronouns

The man saw the woman who is bringing the telescope.

If "who" is with the woman, does this always mean the woman is being referred to, or it can also refer to the man, even though the "who" is mentioned later? Meaning can it also mean the man is bringing the telescope?

Best Answer

The antecedent to a who relative clause is always what precedes it.

There cannot be a space between the who clause and the antecedent to which is refers.

The man saw /the woman who is bringing the telescope/

VERSUS

The man /who is bringing the telescope/ saw the woman.

Two different meanings.

Related Topic