Learn English – dropping things – intentionally and unintentionally

meaning-in-context

Lets look at the first definition of the verb 'drop' by Macmillan

1. to deliberately let something fall
1a. to let sth fall without intending to

So according to the above definitions I dropped my mobile can either mean I dropped it deliberately or I dropped it unintentionally.

My question is how do I differentiate between dropping things deliberately and unintentionally.

If I say to someone that

  1. She dropped the cup and broke it.

So what does it mean ? Did she do it deliberately or it happened unintentionally ?

Best Answer

If you told me that you dropped your phone, I'd assume it was unintentional. (I can't recall ever seeing someone drop their phone on purpose.) When a drop is intentional, that is usually apparent from the context:

She dropped a penny down the wishing well.    (intentional)
He dropped his wallet down the wishing well.    (unintentional)

Naomi dropped her trash into the garbage can.    (intentional)
Paul dropped his glasses into the garbage can.    (unintentional)

The science student dropped the marble onto the lab floor.    (intentional)
The science student dropped the beaker onto the lab floor.    (unintentional)

Rhonda dropped her love letter into the mailbox.         (intentional)
Rhonda dropped her love letter into the storm drain.    (unintentional)

Of course, there's no way to tell for sure – perhaps Rhonda is a recently-jilted lover who is throwing an old letter from her former companion down the sewer drain as an act of contempt; perhaps Paul has recently purchased new eyeglasses and is throwing away his old ones – but there is usually enough context to tell.

Incidentally, this question reminds me of a story that happened to me a long time ago, when my brother and I were young children. Our father took us drop-line fishing off a town bridge; that is, we were using rigs like the one on the left to fish from a bridge like the one on the right:

enter image description here

Anyhow, my line slipped out of my hands and fell into the river. Our father baited my brother's hook, and then said, "Okay, now drop your line in" (meaning, "Put your hook in the water"). My brother (perhaps four years old at the time) threw his line into the river and began to cry.

Our dad asked, "What did you do that for?"

My brother answered, "Well, you told me to drop it in!"

(He thought my dad was trying to be "fair" – since I had lost my line, my brother should lose his, too.)

We went home that day without any fish, but we had a funny story to tell for the rest of our lives.

So, you see, the word drop can be ambiguous in more ways than one.

Related Topic