Passive Voice – Why ‘He Was Seen to Break the Window’ Uses Infinitive

infinitive-vs-gerundpassive-voice

We have a situation: someone saw the boy break the window. Can I make this passive sentence?

The boy was seen to break the window.

I use Murphy's Grammar and this structure is never discussed.

Best Answer

"The boy was seen breaking the window"

... as snailboat recommended is more common, but not more correct. I believe "the boy was seen to break the window" would be grammatically correct.

Consider what happens if you swap "seen" with "known": "The boy was known to break the window." No problem there - that's a common way to say it.

That said, I would still prefer "breaking" over "to break". "The boy was seen breaking the window. He was known to break windows frequently."