Learn English – How to distinguish between descriptive adjectives and classifier adjectives

adjective-orderadjectives

I was reading the book "Practical English Usage" came across with order of adjectives before a noun. Of course the correct order of them! In the book we are reading descriptive adjective must come before classifiers adjectives. for example, the book presents:

"an old political idea"

"latest educational reform"

"leather dancing shoes"

as the correct structures.

Here, the question is why educational can be considered as a classifier while it doesn't hold for leather ? In general, when an adjective lies in the "descriptive"s or the "classifier"s ?

Perhaps, I am addressing difference between classification and description, somehow. I don't know. It mus be noted that I have read the post related to the question of mine, but it does not answer my question
Thanks.

Best Answer

The easiest way for a native speaker to distinguish between a descriptive and classifier adjective is to attempt to intensify it. Consider the following:

  • The old train
  • The very old train
  • The steam train
  • *The very steam train

While you can intensify descriptive adjectives (the very old train), you can't do it to classifiers, at least without some kind of strangeness.

Another test that can be applied is paraphrasing the noun phrase as a sentence that uses the verb be. In the example above, you can say the train is old, but not the train is steam.

You can also try to fit in another classifier before the one you're trying to test:

  • The old teacher
  • *The math old teacher

English doesn't allow for this type of structure if the adjective is descriptive. However, this is a one-way test only - you can't test whether something is a classifier because you can have a classifier followed by another:

  • The revolving doors.
  • The automatic revolving doors.

Of course, this is less straightforward for a non-native speaker, who won't necessarily have that intuition that tells you whether a phrase is grammatical or not.

Some combination of the above is probably going to work for you, with the easiest being the intensifier.

For your specific example, let's apply some tests:

  • "an old political idea"
    the political idea is old - descriptive

  • "latest educational reform"
    The latest reform is educational - descriptive

  • "leather dancing shoes"
    The dancing shoes are leather - descriptive

You can find out more by searching for epithet vs classifier tests, which produced some of the tests I've noted above.

Related Topic