Learn English – how to solve the ambiguity of “in” in this sentence

ambiguitygrammarprepositions

We did the task in ten minutes.

I am pretty sure that it means

1) It took us ten minutes to do the task. (We spent 10 minutes doing the task)

However, I see no obstacle to suppose that it may also mean

2) We did the task after 10 minutes passed.

(That is, "We did the task in ten minutes after we were told". Hence, we might have done the task in 20 seconds but we had been waiting for 10 minutes before we started doing it.

Do you agree that the second meaning which I infer is possible?

Best Answer

There would be possible ambiguity with, for instance:

We'll do the task in ten minutes.

In that case you might be speaking about how long it will be until you do the task, or the duration it will take you to perform it. You're talking about the future; either is possible.

But your sentence is past tense:

We did the task in ten minutes.

So, no. Your interpretation of "We did the task after 10 minutes passed." is not "possible". "in ten minutes" needs a reference point of "now"...and to be read as "ten minutes from now" you must be using present tense.

Related Topic