Learn English – “I would leave tommorow” – is it grammatical

backshiftingfuture-timeprogressive-aspect

Let's say that I utter the following:

I will leave tomorrow.

Would it be ungrammatical to say the following the next day:

I would leave tomorrow.

I know that the following are grammatical and felicitous:

(1) I was going to leave tommorow.

(2) I was leaving tomorrow.

Interestingly, the past simple counterpart of (2) is ungrammatical.

*I left tomorrow.

What do you think?

Best Answer

The sentence, "I would leave tomorrow", is grammatical, but is lacking some sense (subjunctive mood)

The Subjunctive Mood

A verb is in the subjunctive mood when it expresses a condition which is doubtful or not factual. It is most often found in a clause beginning with the word if. It is also found in clauses following a verb that expresses a doubt, a wish, regret, request, demand, or proposal.

Source: http://englishplus.com/grammar/00000031.htm

"If I would leave tomorrow..." (correct)

ALSO:

(1) I was going to leave tommorow. <- WRONG (tomorrow indicates a future time reference, you cannot use it considering the context you provided)

"I am going to leave tomorrow." (correct, the day before leaving) "I left [yesterday]." (arrival)

(2) I was leaving tomorrow. <- WRONG (same as above)

"I will be leaving tomorrow." (correct, the day before leaving) "I left [yesterday]." (arrival)

I will not discuss the use of past progressive here, but I'll provide a link http://www.englishpage.com/verbpage/pastcontinuous.html

*I left tomorrow. <- WRONG (same reason)

You cannot say, "I ate tomorrow" in the same way that you cannot say "I will eat yesterday".

per definition:

tomorrow [tuh-mawr-oh, -mor-oh]

noun

1. the day following today: Tomorrow is supposed to be sunny.

2. a future period or time: the stars of tomorrow.

Since 'tomorrow' is a future time reference, it is wrong to use it in the above quoted sentences. The point here is you cannot simply use a future time reference in a sentence referring to a past action. Also, it is ungrammatical to say "I would leave tomorrow" (in the context the OP provided). 'Will' is a modal used to indicate future tense, hence the main verb's tense should be changed. As above explained, you may use it if you are indicating a subjunctive mood.

Remember that leave/leaves (present); left (PAST); and will leave(future).

Related Topic