Learn English – “it has been written” vs “it is written”

passive-voice

What's the meaning of:

It has been written in bible

To me, it sounds like "It was once written but it doesn't exist there anymore."

It should've been

It is written in bible

because written is a state of being verb, like drunk, etc.

Best Answer

There are several errors in your line of thinking:

1) written is not really a state of being like drunk. We expect drunk people to sober up, but we don't expect written words to disappear.

2) to convey, "It was once written but it doesn't exist there anymore," I would say:

It had been written in the Bible (not has been written)

3) This isn't a matter of one version is right and one version is wrong; both versions could be considered grammatically correct (although I would agree with you that, if the guidance can be found in the Bible, is is probably a better way to say it than has been).

4) We would typically use an article in this context:

It is written in the Bible...
It is written in a book by Tolstoy...

Related Topic