When his grandfather died, he left his grandson a typewriter.
Vs
When his grandfather died, he left his grandson with a typewriter.
Is with required? Or not?
Learn English – “Leave someone something” vs “leave someone with something”
prepositions
prepositions
When his grandfather died, he left his grandson a typewriter.
Vs
When his grandfather died, he left his grandson with a typewriter.
Is with required? Or not?
Best Answer
The first sentence implies that the typewriter was left as part of the grandfather's will. If you are left something after a relative dies, you inherit it.
The second sentence implies it was left there prior to the death of the grandfather, so he is not given the typewriter, it has been left with him.
So it depends on the situation - if it was part of an inheritance, it is not left with, it is just left.