Learn English – “more depressed than her/she”

casegrammar-mythspersonal-pronounssentence-construction

Please explain the error in the following:

He looks more depressed than her but I don't know the reason.

Is there any error in it? My book says her should be replaced by she. This confuses me often, please explain.

Best Answer

Native speakers often say

He looks more depressed than her.

but the objective-case her is considered [has long been considered] to be sub-standard. The standard version is

He looks more depressed than she does.

where "she does" means "she looks depressed".

He looks more depressed than she [looks depressed].

What is being compared is "he looks depressed" versus "she looks depressed".

However, very few native speakers would say:

He looks more depressed than she.

The overwhelming majority would say:

He looks more depressed than she does.

Related Topic