Learn English – ‘That is’ versus ‘That was’

grammaticalityword-choice

Here's an example of what's puzzling me (I'll use a brother/sister arguing example):

SISTER: I couldn't find my homework, so I got an F on the assignment.
BROTHER: You couldn't find your homework because I hid it from you.
SISTER: So that is/was why I couldn't find my homework!

"Couldn't" is past tense, correct? If so, "that was" would seem to be the correct choice to me just because I was told you normally aren't supposed to mix tenses. However, "that is" just sounds correct to me even though it's present tense. So which is correct in this situation (or any other situation that might be similar to this example)?

Best Answer

Both are used and both are acceptable, though you are most likely to hear "that's" rather than "that is/was".

However, "is" cannot be used if the reason, per se, happened in the past.

'Remember when you got an F?'

'Yes. That was because I couldn't find my homework because you hid it.'

Related Topic