Learn English – the difference between “had engaged”, “had been engaged”, and “were engaged” in this context

past-perfectpast-vs-past-perfecttense

Prime Minister Narendra Modi disclosed on Saturday that the registration of over 1 lakh companies which had allegedly engaged in suspicious transactions post demonetisation had been scrapped as he sought to cast the goods and services tax (GST) as his second strike against black money and corruption.

Source:
48 hrs before GST, 1 lakh cos lost registration for post-DeMon `lapses' The Times of India (Mumbai)

Is this sentence construction is correct in above news?
Why Past perfect is used here?

"companies which had allegedly engaged in suspicious transactions"

Or it can be

"companies which had allegedly been engaged in suspicious transactions"

Or it can be

"companies which were allegedly engaged in suspicious transactions"

Best Answer

Why [is the p]ast perfect [...] used here?

Because the main verb of the sentence--disclosed--is in the past tense and the (completed) actions described by the verbs engage and scrap occurred before that disclosure. As has been mentioned, the sentence is not written in the clearest manner possible. That said, its verb tenses are correct and bog standard.

To address the other options:

...had allegedly been engaged...

just adds another layer of opacity to the writing and either means (a) exactly the same thing as the terser phrasing or (b) means that some other entity was responsible for engaging these companies in suspicious transactions. Sense (b) doesn't seem supported by the rest of the context, so it's just making poor phrasing worse.

...were allegedly engaged...

similarly can mean (a) exactly the same thing as the past perfect or (b) shift it into the passive. Again, sense (b) doesn't seem supported. The difference between the first sense and the past perfect is that the same action is being described, but without reference to the occurrence of the main verb. It suggests a more distant relationship between the two verbs.

He had asked her to marry him before she moved to Topeka.

places the question solidly before the completed action of her move to Topeka.

He asked her to marry him before she moved to Topeka.

places the question in the past and removes any connection between the time of the two verbs, leaving it unclear whether she did in fact ever actually leave.

Related Topic