Learn English – The sun is a large object, WHILE having a diameter of nearly a million miles

conjunctions

The Sun is a large object, having a diameter of nearly a million miles. [correct]
The Sun is a large object, while having a diameter of nearly a million miles. [incorrect]

I am wondering the reason for being considered correct or incorrect.

Would you possibly explain why we cannot use while?

I really do appreciate what you taught me.

Nevertheless, I think the second one is just semantically incorrect, while grammatically correct, isn't it?

Meanwhile, as we know one of the usage of while is to be at the same time, so what about the following? if these are correct, so why don't we use while?

The Sun is a large object, while having a diameter of nearly a million miles.

The sun is a large object and it is having a diameter of nearly a million miles.

The sun is a large object and it has a diameter of nearly a million miles.

The sun is a large object which is having a diameter of nearly a million miles.

Best Answer

"while" is used to contrast one situation or thing with another:

The sun is a star, while the moon is a satellite.

In this usage, it is synonymous with "whereas."

Otherwise, "while" used to show that one action is taking place at the same time as another:

My mother knitted while we played a game of Monopoly.

Finally, it can be used to mean "even though":

While I understand your problem, I cannot excuse you from class.

Since none of these meanings can be applied to your example, its use cannot be justified. Hence the sentence is correct without "while," and incorrect with it.

Related Topic