Learn English – Using ‘can’ for possibility

modal-verbs

I wonder if it is possible to use 'can' to signify possibility in the sentence below. I understand that 'could' or 'might' are more suitable here. The context is that we are expecting Jack to call today.

The phone is ringing. It can be Jack.

What is the difference in the meaning if we compare with usage of 'could' or 'might'.

Best Answer

This is an interesting question because logically, it seems like "can" wouldn't necessarily break any grammar rules, but it sure sounds wrong. Willow Rex's comment on the question seems to have the right ring to it. I suspect that there is some context in which "can" would sound right. But the issue seems related to tense. This is my theory:

"Can" is about possibilities. There is a "trick question" used to teach principles of probability. Say you ask someone the question, "I just flipped a coin; what is the probability that it came up heads?" Most people would say 50%. But the answer is actually that it is either 0% or 100%. Probabilities are about the possibility of future events, not things that have already happened and the actual results are final.

That same principle applies to the phone call. A specific person has placed the call and that is the only person it can be, there are no other possibilities. We just don't know who it is. We will discover who it is when we answer the phone (a future event). That also parallels how we think about who it is. We don't think in terms of who theoretically originated the call, we think in terms of who will be at the other end when we pick up.

So knowing who it is is a future condition. "Can" is present tense and "could" is future tense, which makes "could" the appropriate word.

Related Topic