I see both forms, but I've seen in one of the answers here that you use "good in math class" and "not good in math", which is probably not quite true, or is it? Which is it?
I was not gonna ask the question, but after seeing the answer I got more confused.
Here's the link:
Best Answer
The object of at is cast as an activity.
The object of in is cast as a discipline or subject, an area of knowledge.
We can conceptualize math as a subject, or as an activity involving various kind of calculation.