Learn English – Whom-clause Vs who-clause

relative-clauseswho-whom

Michael Swan refers to the whom-clause as "not generally considered correct." In his book, he mentions an example for a 'whom-clause' :

This is a letter from my
father, whom we hope will be out of hospital soon.

He says the above sentence will be "more correct" with who in place of whom.

My questions

  1. Is the the sentence with whom still correct?

  2. I always thought that whom is used in relation to an object rather than a subject, as in:

She is the woman whom you met at my wedding last year.

Restrictiveness aside, I see no difference between Swan's sentence and the above example. Am I missing something here?

Best Answer

Your sentence

This is a letter from my father, whom we hope will be out of hospital soon.

is understandable, but should be

This is a letter from my father, who we hope will be out of hospital soon.

meaning

...we hope he will be to of the hospital soon.

If instead the sentence was phrased as

...we hope the hospital will release him soon.

your sentence could be phrased as

This is a letter from my father, whom we hope the hospital will release soon.

However,

This is a letter from my father, who we hope the hospital will release soon.

would probably also be understood.

Related Topic