Learn English – Why are commas instead of periods used in this sentence from the Economist

punctuation

When reading The Economist, I came across this sentence below in bold. According to grammar, we know a sentence must end up with a full stop, instead of a comma. But in this case, "Mr Trump is the president" and "47% of Americans trust him more than they trust the media" both are sentences, why?


IT WAS almost as if Donald Trump was taunting his Republican
colleagues. After tweeting an explosive and wholly unsubstantiated
claim against Barack Obama on March 4th—“How low has President Obama
gone to tapp [sic] my phones…Bad (or sick) guy!”— the president said
it was up to Congress to investigate the matter. “Neither the White
House nor the president will comment further,” primly declared his
spokesman, Sean Spicer, “until such oversight is conducted.”

Some sort of follow-up is necessary. Mr Trump is the president, 47% of
Americans trust him more than they trust the media (according to a
Quinnipiac poll), and his charge against Mr Obama was grave.
If it
were shown that his administration illegally snooped on Mr Trump, Mr
Obama’s legacy would be disgraced.

(Source: Donald Trump’s habit of making accusations without evidence is corrosive)

Best Answer

The sentence uses three clauses and has the structure:

  • A, B, and C.

The author could have written:

  • A, and B, and C.

  • Mr Trump is the president, and 47% of Americans trust him more than they trust the media (according to a Quinnipiac poll), and his charge against Mr Obama was grave.

However, usually we prefer only to use the word and before the last item in the list. We put a comma between the first two items to show that they are part of the same sentence. We understand a silent and there, even though we do not write it or say it.

The writer has put these three clauses together like this because they form a list of three things which—when we consider them together—provide evidence for their claim that "some sort of follow-up is necessary".

Related Topic