Pronunciation – Why Write /-??/ Instead of /-i?/?

ipaphoneticsphonologypronunciationtranscription

When pronouncing words like "thing", "sing", or any word ending in -ing, I say it and have heard it as "eeng", which would be transcribed as /iŋ/. However, every dictionary I've come across, like Webster's, Oxford, and toPhonetics (I know, not actually a dictionary), transcribe it as /ɪŋ/. I don't think I've ever heard -ing pronounced as "ihng" ('ih' indicates a short vowel as in it), but maybe I'm not listening closely enough.

Is there an explanation as to why it's /ɪŋ/?

Best Answer

Phonemically1 -ing is always /ɪŋ/. The vowel phoneme2 is decided by linguists to be /ɪ/, though it can be realised in many different ways.

Phonetically3, however, it's realised as [iŋ] in some dialects of English (particularly American); that is to say, the vowel [ɪ] raises to [i] due to the effect of the following velar nasal (nasalisation).

According to The Origins and Development of the English Language by John Algeo (p26):

[I]n the South [USA], the vowels [ɪ] and [ɛ], although distinguished in most environments (such as pit and pet), have merged before nasals. Thus pin and pen are homophones for many Southerners, as are tin and ten, Jim and gem, and ping and the first syllable of penguin. The sound used in the nasal environment is usually [ɪ], though before [ŋ] it may approach [i]. [Emphasis mine]



1. /phonemic transcriptions/ are language specific transcriptions i.e. the way dictionaries transcribe words. /They/ can have [many different realisations, depending on the speaker and accent]

2. ‘A phoneme is a mental image of all the various realisations of one and the same sound.’ (Donka Minkova) For example, the phoneme /t/ is a mental image of many realisations such as [t], [tʰ], [t̚], [ʔ] etc., in some dialects of English. By contrast, if you substituted say b for t it would change the meaning (cf. tall and ball) so we would say that /b/ and /t/ are two distinct ‘phonemes’ in English.

3. [phonetic transcriptions] transcribe actual speech sounds i.e how people speak