Learn English – Would + a stative verb

modal-verbsword-choice

As far as I know, here's the main difference between used to and would: used to can be used with both dynamic and stative verbs, whereas would can only be used with dynamic (action) verbs. It's a sentence I saw in a textbook:

He would always know the answers.

Is it OK to use know, which is a stative verb, with would?

Best Answer

You are partially correct in that stative verbs usually relate to a permanent or extended state, and you cannot use would to describe a permanent or extended state. For example, you cannot replace used to with would in these sentences:

My grandma used to live in Indonesia.
We used to live in York.

We use would about regular, habitual actions- a number of separate occasions over a period of time: that's why you can't use it for permanent of extended states.

You are also correct in saying that know can be a stative verb. If you know something, then (assuming you don't forget) it's not a temporary thing.

You can, however, use know in a non-stative way, for example if you were to say

Every time somebody asked a question, John would always know the answer.

What this means is that, on every separate occasion that a question was asked, John did, on every separate occasion, know the answer.

This link provides more background information about would and used to.