Grammar – Difference Between ‘I Can’t Imagine…’ and ‘I Don’t Imagine…’

grammargrammaticality-in-context

Swan says in his book Advanced Oxford Grammar that we usually use this construction:

I don't imagine + affirmative verb

E.g. I don't Imagine John will read the instructions I sent him.

I've been comparing this construction with I can't imagine …. My question is, do they have the same meaning, even though they are differed by the verb and modal?

I've tried to search related problems involving **I can't imagine… ** provided here:

  1. can-t-begin-to-imagine-understand-explain-etc.
  2. I can't imagine John is driving a car.

Both links gave me a sense that those forms I've mentioned before are the same in meaning. However, I want to know if it turns out they are extremely different.

Best Answer

"I don't imagine..." states without emphasis that, in your opinion, something is probably untrue.

"I can't imagine..." adds emphasis by suggesting that, in your opinion, something is vanishingly unlikely.