Tense for a Stopped Clock – Sentence Construction and Tense Usage

sentence-constructiontense

When you found that your clock was not working, and you don't know when it had stopped, how would you say it?

  1. It was working last night, but it didn't work this morning.
  2. It was working last night, but it wasn't working this morning.
  3. It was working last night, but it isn't working this morning.
  4. It was working last night, but it doesn't work this morning.

I would like to put "this morning" there to mean "It wasn't working when I saw it in the morning, and it has stopped until now, 11:00 a.m."

  • I edited the title: mention about a clock → mention a clock

Best Answer

As @AstralBee has mentioned, you don't need to repeat the words:

It was working last night but not this morning.

Personally I think all 4 sentences are fine, but I might prefer (1).

Plus the tense doesn't change for all 4 of your sentences anyways.

Related Topic