Phrase Meaning – Which of Them vs Which One of Them vs Who Among Them

phrase-meaning

Do these sentences have absolutely the same meaning, or does the word "one" change something? Does it just emphasize that the speaking is about one certain person?

Which of them is your husband?

Which one of them is your husband?

P.S. What about a question "Who among them is your husband?"? Is it idiomatic?

Best Answer

Yes, they have the same meaning - also "Which one is your husband?"

Who among them is not very idiomatic for identifying an individual. You might use it for asking whether something applies to any member(s) of a group.

Who among them has been vaccinated?